Italy – 80% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 8.94 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 99%
·
Life expectancy at birth: 81.95 Years
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 3.33 Per 1,000 births
·
GDP Per capita: $30,600
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 62.7%
Spain – 94% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 10.14 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 97.7%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 81.37
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 3.35 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $31,100
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 65.7%
Mexico – 82.7% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 18.61 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 93.5%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 76.86
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 16.26 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $15,600
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 70.9%
Brazil – 73.6% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 14.97 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 90.4%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 73.02
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 19.83 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $12,100
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 80.3%
France – 83-88% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 12.6 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 99%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 81.56
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 3.34 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $39,771.84
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 76.4%
Argentina – 92% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 17.12 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 97.9%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 77.32
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 10.24 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $18,400
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 78.9%
Outgroup
Japan - <2% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 8.23 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 99%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 84.19
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 2.17 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $36,900
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 54.3%
Russia - <2% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 11.21 births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 99.7%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 69.85
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 7.19 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $14,307
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 79.5%
Iran - <1% Roman
Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 18.4
births per 1,000 Population
·
Literacy rate: 85%
·
Life Expectancy at birth: 70.62
·
Infant Mortality Rate: 40.02 per 1,000 births
·
GDP per capita: $6,815.57
·
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 73.3%
Analysis:
As my countries containing large
Roman Catholic populations, I looked at Italy, Spain, Mexico, Brazil, France,
and Argentina. For the outgroup of countries with low populations of Roman
Catholics, I looked at Japan, Russia, and Iran. For my data variables I chose
Birth rate, Literacy rate (as a measure of education), life expectancy at birth
and infant mortality rate (as measures of healthcare), GDP per capita (as a measure
of wealth and lifestyle), and contraceptive prevalence rate.
Even though
contraception is banned by the Roman Catholic Church, there does not appear to
be a correlation between being a Catholic nation and having low rates of
contraception use. On the contrary, Brazil, a heavily Catholic nation has the
highest rate of contraception use, and other Catholic countries have about the
same rates as the non-Catholic countries I looked at.
There were,
however, some correlations that I saw in the data. First, countries with high
Infant Mortality Rates also tended to have higher birth rates. This makes sense
because if a mother is going to have the same number of children reach
adulthood, she must have more babies since some of them will not live past
infancy. Along with this correlation, the nations with the highest infant
mortality rates had the lowest GDPs per capita. This shows that undeveloped
countries tend to have higher infant mortality rates and worse healthcare.
There did not seem to be large correlations between education (literacy rates)
and contraception, although Iran had the lowest literacy rate and the highest
infant mortality rate and the second lowest expected lifespan, suggesting that
there might be a correlation between education and healthcare.
Nations with high percentage of
Catholic citizens:
1.
Spain
Birth Rate:
10.14 births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 94%
Infant mortality
rate: 3.35 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 29.3
Literacy rate: 97.7%
Life expectancy:
81.37 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $31,100
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 65.7%
2.
Mexico
Birth Rate:
18.61 births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 82.7%
Infant mortality
rate: 16.26 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 21.3
Literacy rate:
93.5%
Life expectancy:
76.86 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $15,600
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 70.9%
3.
Peru
Birth Rate:
18.85 births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 81.3%
Infant mortality
rate: 20.85 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 22.3
Literacy rate:
89.6%
Life expectancy:
72.98 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $10,900
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 68.9%
4.
Argentina
Birth Rate:
17.12 births/1,000 population
Percentage of Catholics:
92%
Infant mortality
rate: 10.24 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: N/A
Literacy rate:
97.9%
Life expectancy:
77.32 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $18,400
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 78.9%
5.
Italy
Birth Rate: 8.94
births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 80% Christian (overwhelming majority is Roman Catholic)
Infant mortality
rate: 3.33 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 27.7
Literacy rate:
99%
Life expectancy:
81.95 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $30,600
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 62.7%
6.
Brazil
Birth Rate:
14.97 births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 73.6%
Infant mortality
rate: 19.83 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: N/A
Literacy rate:
90.4%
Life expectancy:
73.02 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $12,100
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 80.3%
Outgroup: Nations with no evident
religious or ideological restrictions on contraceptive use
1.
Australia
Birth Rate:
12.23 births/1,000 population
Percentage of Catholics:
25.8%
Infant mortality
rate: 4.49 deaths/1,000 births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 30.5
Literacy rate:
99%
Life expectancy:
81.98 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $43,300
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 72.3%
2.
Finland
Birth Rate:
10.36 births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 1.1% or less
Infant mortality
rate: 3.38 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 27.9
Literacy rate: 100%
Life expectancy:
79.55 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $37,000
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: N/A
3.
Japan
Birth Rate: 8.23
births/1,000 population
Percentage of
Catholics: 2% or less
Infant mortality
rate: 2.17 deaths/1,000 live births
Mother’s mean
age at first birth: 29.4
Literacy rate:
99%
Life expectancy:
84.19 years
GDP per capita
(PPP): $36,900
Contraceptive
prevalence rate: 54.3%
For the countries with large populations
of Catholic citizens, I chose Spain, Mexico, Peru, Argentina, Italy, and
Brazil, while for the outgroup nations, I chose Australia, Finland, and Japan.
I decided to examine each nation’s respective birth rates, infant mortality
rates, mothers’ mean ages at first birth, literacy rates, life expectancies,
GDPs per capita, and the contraceptive prevalence rates. As discussed briefly
in class, it appears that a high percentage of Catholicism has little
correlation with a high birth rate, as countries such as Spain and Italy have
significantly lower birth rates than countries like Mexico, Peru, Brazil, and
Argentina. While the Catholic religion explicitly bans use of birth control, it
appears that this is not a sanction that is consistently followed among every
majorly Catholic nation; rather, it appears that there are other factors at
play.First and foremost, countries with higher infant mortality rates, such as
Mexico, Brazil, and Argentina, which had the greatest mean number of deaths per
1,000 live births (of the countries I surveyed), tended to have far higher
birth rates than countries with lower infant mortality rates, religious makeup
notwithstanding. That is, with countries such as Japan, Italy, Spain and
Finland, which had the lowest birth rates as well as lowest infant mortality
rates (of the countries I surveyed) having a majority Catholic population does
not mean that the prohibition of contraceptive use is a rule that is being
followed in actual behavior. Another factor that could be related to birth rate
is the mother’s mean age at first birth, which tended to be lower (early 20s)
in countries with higher birth rates like Mexico and Peru and higher (late
20s/early 30s) in countries like Australia and Japan. The countries with higher
birth rates also had lower standards of living, as reflected in their GDPs per
capita. This leads me to believe that lower standards of living might well be
related to higher infant mortality rates and thus higher birth rates, as giving
birth to more children could be a means of combating the greater chances of
losing an infant once they are born, no matter the predominant religion of the
country. In addition, it could be likely that the women in these countries are
having babies earlier in their lives because they face more risks and lower
quality of life, which means they need to start earlier to have more children
in case any of them die. While the countries with higher birth rates did tend
to have, on average, somewhat lower literacy rates and life expectancies, these
did not appear to be significant enough to indicate any type of correlation
between the factors. In addition, the respective contraceptive prevalence rates
seemed to have no correlation with birth rates at all, for the similarity of
prevalence of contraceptives in countries such as Peru, with a birth rate of
18.85/1,000, and Spain, with a birth rate of 10.14/1,000, simply did not match
up with the discrepancies in birth rate.
Lauren Week
Aryella Moreh
Nations with Notable Catholic Populations:
Mexico:
76.5% Roman Catholic
19.13 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 17.29 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 76.5 years
School life expectancy: 14 years
Spain
96% Roman Catholic
10.66 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 3.39 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 81.2 years
School life expectancy: 17 years
School life expectancy: 17 years
Italy
90% Roman Catholic
9.18 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 3.38 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 81.7 years
School life expectancy: 16 years
Philippines
83% Catholic
24.62 births/1000 pupulation
Infant mortality: 18.19 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 72.21 years
School life expectancy: 11 years
Brazil
73.6% Roman Catholic
14.97 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 19.83 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 73.02 years
School life expectancy: 14 years
Andorra
94% Roman Catholic
8.88 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 3.73 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 82.58 year
School life expectancy: 12 years
Nations without Notable Catholic Populations
Algeria
0.01% Roman Catholic
24.25 births/1000
Infant mortality: 22.57 deaths/1000
Life expectancy: 76.18 years
School life expectancy: 14 years
Armenia
3.7% Roman Catholic
12.86 births/1000
Infant mortality: 17.59 deaths/1000
Life expectancy: 73.75 years
School life expectancy: 12 years
Djibouti
0.2% Catholic
24.5 births/1000 population
Infant mortality: 51.77 deaths/1000 births
Life expectancy: 61.99 years
School life expectancy: 6 years
*Conclusions/Analysis:
I examined birth rates, infant mortality, overall life expectancy, and education levels of counties in order to study the relationship between Catholicism and birth rates. Although we would assume that countries with notable Catholic populations would have higher birthrates in accordance with the papal edict against birth control, based on the evidence provided by these nine countries, there seems to be an insignificant relationship between Catholicism and birth rate. Rather, the evidence seems to demonstrate a strong correlation between the birth rate and infant mortality.
The correlation between birth rate and infant mortality levels reflects patters of r-selection and K-selection. The r/K Selection Theory is a model used to understand reproductive adaptation based on parental investment and the quality and quantity of offspring. Organisms that follow the model of K-selection bear fewer offspring, but experience lower infant mortality. They are adapted to a stable environment and recognize that there are few resources available. Also, they are heavily invested in their offspring. Moreover, organisms that follow the model of r-selection bear more offspring, but experience high levels of infant mortality. They inhabit unstable and resource-poor environments. Also, they are less invested in their offspring than K-selected species. In general, animals with reliable but limited resources tend to bear few offspring in which they are highly invested. In contrast, animals with unreliable resources bear many offspring with the knowledge that few will survive to a viable age—demonstrating that patterns of reproduction are determined by environmental factors. This tendency is strongly present in humans as well, as illustrated by the data provided by these nine countries.
Furthermore, these nine countries generally illustrated a correlation between education and birth rate. Aside from Andorra, the countries with a school life expectancy of 14 years or lower also had high birth rates and high levels of infant mortality. This reflects the tendency of parents following the K-selection patter of reproduction to have higher levels of education.
Countries like Italy or Spain, followed the K-selection model of reproduction, reflected by lower birth rates and low levels of infant mortality. In contrast, countries like Djibouti (which does not have a notable Catholic population) and Mexico (which does have a notable Catholic population), followed the r-selection model, reflected by high birthrates and high mortality rates. It is evident that the high birth rates correspond with high levels of infant mortality. Applying the model of r-selection, it can be assumed that these high birth rates are a response to high levels of infant mortality, in order to maintain the population despite unstable environmental conditions.
Alicia Fong
Data:
Philippines
·
82.9% Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 24.63 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy at birth: 72.21
years
·
Infant mortality rate: 18.19
deaths/1,000 live births
Italy
·
90% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 9.18 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy at birth: 81.7 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 3.38 deaths/1,000 live
births
Spain
·
96% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 10.66 births /1,000 population
·
Life expectancy: 81.2 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 3.39 deaths/1000 live
births
Mexico
·
76.5% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 19.13 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy: 76.5 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 17.29 deaths/1,000 live
births
France
·
83%-88% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 12.6 births/1,000
population
·
Life expectancy: 81.56 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 3.34
deaths/1,000 live births
Poland
·
89.8% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 9.88 births/1,000
population
·
Life expectancy: 76.45 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 6.3
deaths/1,000 live births
Indonesia
·
3% Roman Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 17.38 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy: 71.9 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 26.06
deaths/1,000 live births
Japan
·
.40% Catholics
·
Birth Rate: 8.23 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy: 84.19 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 2.17
deaths/1,000 live births
Sweden
·
1.6% Catholic
·
Birth Rate: 10.33 births/1,000 population
·
Life expectancy: 81.28 years
·
Infant mortality rate: 2.73
deaths/1,000 live births
Based on the data, it is clear that
there is no correlation between birth rate and the practice of Catholicism. The
assumption that countries with a higher percentage of practicing Catholics having
a higher birth rate than those countries that have a lower percentage of practicing
Catholic is false. The Philippines, Italy, Spain, Mexico, France and Poland are
all countries with Catholic populations higher than 75%, and yet their birth
rates range from 24.62 births/1,000 population to 9.18
births/1,000 population. Meanwhile, Indonesia, Japan and Sweden are countries
with a Catholic population lower than 5%, and their birth rates also range from
high to low, similar to the countries with high Catholic populations. It is
clear that just because a country has a high percentage of practicing Catholics
does not mean that their birth rate will be higher than those who do not.
Despite the low use of birth
control in countries with high Catholic percentages, the birth rate is not
controlled by the practicing religion of the respective countries. There could
be other factors in play here, such as the how-to-knowledge and the successful
education of the public about contraceptives, depending on if the country is a
third-world country or not. Overall, it is safe to say that birth rate is not
based on the majority of religion in the case of practicing Catholicism.
Debbie Phoung
Clement Tam
6 Nations (>65%
Catholics)
Argentina
Catholics: 92%
Birth rate: 17.12/1,000
Death rate: 7.35/1,000 (0.735%)
Infant mortality rate: 10.24/100,000
(0.01%)
Average lifespan: 77.32 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 78.9%
Literacy: 97.9%
School life expectancy: 16 years
GDP per capita: $18,400
Unemployment: 7.2%
Population below poverty line: 30%
|
Cape Verde
Catholics: 92.64%
Birth rate: 20.96/1,000
Death rate: 6.22/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 25.13/1,000
Average Lifespan: 71.28
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 61.3%
Literacy: 84.9%
School life expectancy: 13 years
GDP per capita: $4,200
Unemployment: 21%
Population below poverty line: 30%
|
Ecuador
Catholics: 95%
Birth rate: 19.23/1,000
Death rate: 5.03/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 18.48/1,000
Average Lifespan: 76.15 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 72.7%
Literacy: 91.6%
School life expectancy: 14 years
GDP per capita: $10,200
Unemployment: 4.9%
Population below poverty line: 27.3%
|
Italy
Catholics: 90%
Birth rate: 8.94/1,000
Death rate: 10.01/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 3.33/1,000
Average Lifespan: 81.95
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 62.7%
Literacy: 99%
School life expectancy: 16 years
GDP per capita: $30,600
Unemployment: 10.6%
Population below poverty line: 19.6%
|
Mexico
Catholics: 82.7%
Birth rate: 18.61/1,000
Death rate: 4.94/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 16.26/1,000
Average Lifespan: 78.86
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 70.9%
Literacy: 93.5%
School life expectancy: 14 years
GDP per capita: $15,600
Unemployment: 5%
Population below poverty line: 51.3%
|
Poland
Catholics: 89.8% (75% practicing)
Birth rate: 9.88/1,000
Death rate: 10.31/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 6.3/1,000
Average Lifespan: 76.45
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 72.7%
Literacy: 99.7%
School life expectancy: 15 years
GDP per capita: $20,900
Unemployment: 12.8%
Population below poverty line: 10.6%
|
OUTGROUP: 3 Nations
(<5% Catholics)
Japan
Catholics: 0.4%
Birth rate: 8.23/1,000
Death rate: 9.27/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 2.17/1,000
Average Lifespan: 84.19
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 54.3%
Literacy: 99%
School life expectancy: 15 years
GDP per capita: $36,900
Unemployment: 4.4%
Population below poverty line: 16%
|
Afghanistan
Catholics: 0.0003%
Birth rate: 39.05/1,000
Death rate: 14.35/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 119.41/1,000
Average Lifespan: 50.11
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 21.8%
Literacy: 28.1%
School life expectancy: 8 years
GDP per capita: $1,100
Unemployment: 35%
Population below poverty line: 36%
|
Egypt
Catholics: 0.35%
Birth rate: 23.79/1,000
Death rate: 4.79/1,000
Infant mortality rate: 23.3/1,000
Average Lifespan: 73.19 years
Contraceptive prevalence rate: 60.3%
Literacy: 73.9%
School life expectancy: 12 years
GDP per capita: $6,700
Unemployment: 13.5%
Population below poverty line: 20%
|
Analysis/Conclusion
In the above tables, I have gathered
statistical data on nine different nations, particularly focusing on the
statistics for the percentage of Catholics, birth rate, death rate, infant
mortality rate, average lifespan, contraceptive prevalence rate, literacy,
school life expectancy, GDP per capita, unemployment, and population below
poverty line. The first six nations are nations that have greater than 65% of
the population that are Catholics. The other 3 nations are the outgroup where
less than 5% of the population are Catholics.
There is the general position that
artificial birth control is prohibited among practitioners of Catholicism. With
this fact, there is a reasonable assumption that nations with large Catholic
populations would have birth rates that reflect an absence of birth control
measures, which means higher birth with less birth control. This also means
that nations that do not have a significant population that is prohibited from
using artificial birth control measures would have lower birth rates. However,
according to the statistics listed above that were collected from nine nations,
these assumptions are not valid.
There
is the assumption that if there is less birth control, then there would be
higher birth rate. However, if we look at the statistics above with the 6
nations that have greater than 65% Roman Catholics in their population and
compare it with the outgroup, it is evident that this is not true. The birth
rates for the outgroup, with the exception of Japan, are much higher than the
birth rates for the six nations. Afghanistan and Egypt have a birth rate of
about 39.05 births/1,000 population and 23.79 births/1,000 population,
respectively, while the six nations that are heavily Catholic have a much lower
birth rate. If the assumptions were valid, these statistics should be reversed.
The birth rate for the six nations that are heavily populated with Catholics
should have higher birth rates than the nations that are not heavily Catholic.
This leads us to believe that a high percentage of Catholicism does not have a
correlation with a high birth rate, and that there are other variables that
appear to correlate more closely with birth rates than religious belief.
In
accordance with the statistics above, the conclusion can be made that there are
other factors contributing to birth rate. If we look at the six nations, they
all have similar statistics in regards to infant mortality rate, average
lifespan, average income, and average education level. All the six nations have
relatively low mortality rate, a high average lifespan (about 70-80 years), a
decent sustainable income, and high literacy rates. Taking this into account
and considering the k-selection/k-strategy, there is fewer offspring when there
is lower mortality rate and high education levels. Also if we take the
statistics from Japan in the outgroup, they look similar to the statistics of
the other six nations. Because this nation is low in population of Catholics,
the assumption should be that they should have a lower birth rate, however, it
has a similar birth rate as the other six nations. This can be accounted to the
fact that they are a literate country with low mortality rate. Therefore, it
can be assumed that these factors play a part in birth rate. As further
evidence that these factors play a part in birth rate, we need to look at the
statistics for Afghanistan and Egypt. These nations should have a low birth
rate under the assumption that they have a low population of Catholics (more
birth control = lower birth rate). However, we see that their birth rates are
high. And if we look at the statistics for infant mortality rate, they are
relatively high (119.41births/1,000 population and 23.3 births/1,000
population) compared to the other six nations. Their average lifespan and
literacy rates are also relatively low. Looking at these patterns, it is
evident that the assumptions made about Catholicism having a correlation with a
high birth rate are invalid. There are other variables that appear to correlate
more closely with birth rates, such as mortality rate, average lifespan,
income, and education.
Clement Tam
Question: Do nations with higher populations of Catholics have higher birthrates as a result of the Papal Encyclical Humanae Vitae from Pope Paul VI denouncing the use of birth control.
Study Group:
Country
|
% of population that are Catholic
|
Birth rate per 1000 people
|
Infant Mortality Rate per 1000 births/Rank in the world
|
Death Rate
Per 1000 people
|
Life Expectancy
|
Literacy Rate
|
GDP per capita in USD
|
Paraguay
|
91
|
16.95
|
21/86th
|
4.61
|
76.6
|
93.9%
|
$6,200
|
Monaco
|
90
|
6.79
|
1.8/224th
|
8.75
|
89.63
|
99%
|
$70,700
|
Ireland
|
83
|
15.5
|
3.78/203rd
|
6.4
|
80.44
|
99%
|
$42,300
|
Spain
|
94
|
10.14
|
3.35/214th
|
8.94
|
81.37
|
97.7
|
$31,100
|
Argentina
|
92
|
17.12
|
10.24/143rd
|
7.35
|
77.32
|
97.9
|
$18,400
|
Philippines
|
81
|
24.62
|
18.19/99th
|
4.95
|
72.21
|
95.4%
|
$4500
|
Out group:
Country
|
% of population that are Catholic
|
Birth rate per 1000 population
|
Infant Mortality Rate
|
Death Rate
Per 1000 people
|
Life Expectancy
|
Literacy Rate
|
GDP per capita
|
Norway
|
5
|
10.8
|
3.47
|
9.21
|
80.44
|
100%
|
$55,900
|
Niger
|
0.1
|
46.84
|
87.98
|
13.07
|
54.34
|
28.7%
|
$800
|
Bulgaria
|
1
|
9.07
|
15.6
|
14.31
|
74.08
|
98.4%
|
$14,500
|
Conclusions:
Based on the data from the randomly selected nations in the “Study Group”, it appears that the fact that they were Catholic had little to no impact on their birthrates. Take for instance the country of Monaco. It has one of the lowest birthrates in the world, but has a Catholic population of 90%. Additionally, if you examine the statistics of Spain, the data indicates that its birth rate is not relatively very high considering that the nation is 94% Catholic. Both these nations have low infant mortality rates and relatively high GDP per capita. It appears, at least in the “Study Group” that birth rates were determined more by a combination of factors including the GDP per capita, and the infant mortality rate than whether or not the nation was predominantly populated by Catholics. This trend is evidenced by the statistics of the nations of Paraguay and the Philippines, both those nations have relatively low GDP per capita and relatively high infant mortality rates and coincidentally have higher birth rates. It would appear that infant mortality rates and income are the major factors that influence birth rates. Infant mortality rate is an influences most likely because, as humans, we are seeking to propagate our species. This is done through having kids. If the rate at which our kids die is greater than the rate at which they are produced, then the chances of propagating are significantly affected in the negative. GDP per capita is also a factor, because GDP is a figure used to measure the relative wealth of a nation via is economic output. Countries with lower GDP’s tend to have lower standards of living and more dilapidated infrastructure. This implies that living conditions and thus chances of living a comfortable life are lower. Literacy rates appear to not have much of an impact as they are pretty standard across the board.
The out group nations also echoed the conclusion that birthrates appear tied to GDP and infant mortality rate. Norway, Niger and Bulgaria do not have a significant population that subscribed to a major relation. They also have low percentages of their population who are Catholics. The best example of this trend in the out group is the country of Niger. Niger has the highest birth rate out of all the nations in the world. It has a GDP per capita of $800 and an infant mortality rate of 87.9 per 1000 live births. It would appear that the low incomes and associated living conditions contribute to the high infant mortality rate. In order to compensate for this and maintain the population equilibrium, the birth rate is higher. The is especially apparent when that nation is juxtaposed with a nation like Norway which has a lower birth rate, high GDP per capita and low infant mortality rate.
*It is important to note that there is a slight trend that nations with lower literacy rates have slightly higher birthrates than nations with higher literacy rates.
* It is also important to note that Ireland seems to be an outlier in this study. It has a relatively high literacy rate and GDP per capita and a low infant mortality rate, but has a relatively high birth rate when compared to other nations in the study group. It would appear that the statistics of this nation may indicated the effectiveness of the Papal Encyclical Humanae Vitae.
*It is also important to note that Bulgaria is an outlier in the “out group.” It has a relatively high infant mortality rate but has a birth rate that does not seem to compensate for it.
No comments:
Post a Comment